Siciliano's

Reviews about Siciliano's

• 4 / 5

  By Cortnei Bruce
  Best pizza on the islands! It is true that the place is a bit dim and grungy, but that's what gives it character. Those are my favorite types of bars to go to when I want to stay near home and just get of the house a bit. I hope they never change. The folks with the poor reviews should have just ordered delivery and enjoyed this awesome food in an environment that more suits their needs.
  March 10, 2017
• 2 / 5

  By Dominic Ottaviano
  Huge slices are a plus and the atmosphere is that of an old school pizza place which I like. Had to wait about 5 minutes at the counter to get Parmesan cheese and crushed red pepper only to come back and realize we didn't have napkins or utensils at the table either and go find those. Garlic knots were pretty dry and burnt on the bottom pizza was fair but is cooked on a conveyor belt so not really New York style. Being in a tourist area is probably the best place around if you do want a slice of pizza though. Update: lowered it to a 2 from a 3. Can't get any service had to go up and ask for a to go box which the guy was too busy playing on his phone and looked up like I was bothering him. Told him I had two slices and handed me one small Styrofoam container? This place just all around sucks but don't have the heart to give a locally owned place 1 star.
  December 17, 2016
• 5 / 5

  By David & Gaby
  Scott Jackson the owner has done a fantastic job making this hang out well -laid out, warm and inviting. It's cool that he's often around to chat it up with. Great hot sandwiches.
  -David Bradford
  June 14, 2016